Saturday 11 June 2011

Freedom!

We love it when people comment on the blog - that's the idea, for us to 'Think Allowed'. Recently, we took the unusal step of deleting a comment - and that sparked some comments! One of those suggested that we should do a post on freedom - and we freely decided that was a good idea!

We love to think of ourselves as these amazing, independent creatures, evaluating options and freely coming to our own mature, sure we are right, decision. Freedom of choice, freedom to speak, free to live the life we want is many peoples highest goal. 'I did it my way' is the iconic song.

In reality of course, no choice we make is completely free. There are influences on every decision we make, consequences that have to be taken into account. For example, I am writing this from a cafe in Chiang Mai, Thailand. I'm here because I chose to be, but it wasn't a 'free' choice. In fact there were a number of costs - financial was but one; there's the long-haul flight, the heat and humidity and of course the time away from those I love.  On the plus side of course there's the opportunity to be somewhere I've never been before and the chance to input into the lives of the leaders and trainees that we had invested in during our time in Carlisle. Sometimes the influences can seem overwhelming - as if we have no actual choice. But scripture tells us that 'a bruised reed, I will not break', 'a smouldering candle I will not extinguish'. There are boundaries around the influences, no matter how powerful they seem, we always have choice. Love does not insist on it's own way.

So how do we choose? So often we don't ask 'who is trying to influence us, what other self-interests are in play?' We simply take the costs and benefits; weigh it up, make the decision. Do the benefits seem to outweigh the costs, if so do it, if not, don't. Of course, it isn't always as explicit as that, we don't sit down with a spreadsheet and evaluate it this way... often it will be a gut feeling rather than an intellectual process, nonetheless, that's what in our heart and mind we have done..

It's a seductive process, it gives the illusion that we are in control, masters of our own destiny, but of course it just isn't true. One persons freedom to comment on a blog may result in someone else not having the freedom to be at peace. If everyone chooses what is best for them, at some point their choices will not be good for me and given there are more others than there are of me, this cannot be good news! Similarly, the influences from some quarters may seem plausible, but behind them may be malicious intent - whether mildly in advertising, more dangerous in propaganda or fatally, the direct lies of the enemy.  But even if we are able to accurately assess and give appropriate credence to the influences, we do not have all the facts - ever.

We don't have the full picture, we have no clue as to the full consequences and implications of our choices. So often, we make our choices on the basis of narrow self-interest, based on incomplete information, blind to the mailcious intent behind some of the influences!

In society, democracy attempts to mitigate some of these issues. It provides a crude means for taking into account the interests of others. It provides a legal framework in which individual freedoms are curtailed for the benefit of the whole. But that still leaves the problem that we are poor judges of what is good for us. The internet provides the illusion of personal omniscience, but in truth, Wikipidea is a poor substitute for God's knowledge. It would surely be good to make decisions in the light of a broader wisdom than ours alone.

So what about decision making, freedom in the Kingdom?

Jesus, faced the hardest decision ever - to go to a cross or call on the Father to destroy the world with 'more than 12 legions of angels'. He made the decision based on the full picture. A picture only available through the Spirit and only believable through faith. Human insight and demonic influence all pointed a different way. 'You want to die for people who want to kill you?', 'God has deserted you, make an end to it now'. It was an agonising decision, one which flew in the face of seemingly overwhelming influence. Yet, 'for the joy set before him, he endured the cross, despising its shame' In human terms, the shame and anguish of the cross, the death it guaranteed far outweighed any benefit. Yet because of this divinely revealed bigger picture, Jesus was able to over-ride the cost and choose instead the way that would bring real freedom for us.

We can do the same. We can choose against self-interest. We can make choices on a divinely revealed bigger picture. We can choose the hard road, the narrow path, the shadowy valley. We can go from Albainia to India and spend our life serving the outcasts. We can go from Middle Class Britain to Albania and serve people there. We can choose against the mere economics of what's in it for me. We can lay down our rights to our freedoms and be like Jesus.

Strangely, in this topsy-turvy Kingdom, as we lay down our life we find life. As we make ourselves vulnerable we are protected, as we empty ourselves we are filled, as we make ourselves poor we become rich. As we submit our will to that of Jesus, we become freer than ever before.

If the son shall set you free, you shall be free indeed.

Feel free to comment.

11 comments:

  1. I find that hard to swallow, today. Actions speak louder than words although I don't hear many words at the moment. Does my Human Rights give me the freedom to comment as I wish? I understand that even illegal immigrants cannot be turned away now as it is their against their human rights to send them awaY. This really means that we have the LEGAL right to do or say ANYTHING we like as it is our Human Right to do so, so maybe legally you should reinstate whatever comment it was that was deleted; you acted against someone's Human Right.

    ReplyDelete
  2. http://youtu.be/mOnCqFM7Aus

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thought provoking. Brings to mind 'And the peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.'
    Philippians 4:6-8. '...transcends all understanding...'. We are in a battle, but not alone. (sorry to state the obvious, but I need to remind myself this every day).

    ReplyDelete
  4. It seems to me that virtually everything we do has implications outside of ourselves and most things we do are as a result of other people's actions or expectations. We may like to think that we have the right to be free to do as we wish but until the time that we are all making perfect choices, life is very messy. We have to chart a course through it using integrety but sometimes being prepared to curtail our freedoms for the sake of others' well-being. While we live in a world where the enemy is muddying the water perhaps the only true authentic freedom we can expereince is as we stand before God's throne and hear Him say that because of His death on the cross we are free to be the person He made us to be. Maybe that truth doesn't make the day to day decision making any easier but it certainly changes 'my right' to impose my freedom in the world around me because I know deep down that I AM FREE.
    Penny Jones

    ReplyDelete
  5. Confidence in God as my judge, vindicator, sustainer, provider (and much more) gives me the freedom (when I remember those truths) to act in a manner which benefits the wider community. "Human Rights" is not a completely bad idea, but the individualism with which it is often worked out today is a denial to your well-made point, David, about finding life by laying it down. Ultimate "freedom" leads to anarchy. I know people here in Albania who remember a period of anarchy in 1997 when children carried rocket launchers on the streets, and whoever had the will and power expressed it as they wished. Freedom for a very few, maybe, but fear and destruction for the many -- and the country is still paying, literally, for it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. @ Brian : It is your Human Right to do anything now. Once you utter those 2 powerful words, you can get away with anything.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Interesting blog. We are doing freedom in Christ at our church and that is a good step to freedom - it's about our daily choices. Choice, is a good word to use in a blog about freedom. It's whether or not we make wise choices but in the end we will all come before god who will judge us on the choices we make thank goodness he sent his son Jesus to carry all the wrong choices we make! But it's also up to us to acknowledge bad choices we cannot blame others how much we would like to..!..

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't think I will post on a blog where the moderators freely admit to deleting posts, especially when they offer no explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Interesting discussion! I think there is probably much debate about individual rights in online forums - however I do think that when a person or group takes responsibility for an online space such as a blog, it should be their right to decide what is inapropriate.. Especially when people can comment anonymously and give any sort of opinion, with whatever tone - even if this forum may not be the best place. One of the wonderful things about the internet is that anyone who wants something different can start their own blog! However, I'm certain that even quite controvertial ideas can be communicated in a non-offensive way - i'm sure there must have been just cause for deletion of the comment.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Well I said i wouldn't comment and I won't on the substance of this blog. It actually doesn't deserve the title 'blog'. It's more Like a group of people of the same view chatting in a closed room. If someone disagrees their view is deleted. The previous anonymous feels the deleted comment was deleted with just cause. If so let us hear the reason. The truth will set you free.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Mmm I agree - that definition sounds like a cult. disappointing there is no response from who runs the blog

    ReplyDelete